Diana Meltsner
  • Home
  • Classes
  • Yoga Therapy
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

On Worship and Yoga

12/15/2023

5 Comments

 
Picture
Yoga came to us here in the West from a highly devotional culture of India where the worship of multiple Deities has been part of people’s lives for many centuries on an everyday basis.

I first learned about Yoga in college from a book by Swami Sivananda and then I found the Integral Yoga Institute here in San Francisco just before the turn of the century. I learned Yoga has much more to it than just physical postures and breathing. The complexity of Yoga and the positive influence that it has had on my life keeps me interested as I continue to learn, share with others and awaken. Swami Satchidananda, the founder of Integral Yoga brought teachings of Yoga and its many practices to the United States a long time ago, before I was even born. Path of Bhakti Yoga and its devotional practices were part of it. Bhakti Yoga is considered the Yoga of the Heart.

How does prayer and worship as traditionally practiced in Yoga translate to a non-Hindu society? After more than 50 years, did it take? Is it possible to participate with full authenticity in devotional rituals that call on Hindu Gods and Goddesses? The kirtan practice, call and response chanting is widely popular here in the Bay Area. This singing of holy names is no less ecstatic than praising the Lord with Gospel music. As we call the names of Hindu deities, can we relate to them more than to the Gods and Goddesses of the old Roman mythology? 

These are questions we have to ask ourselves and search our hearts. I believe it is through the authentic expression of spirituality and aligning fully with the Truth as we perceive it, we begin to awaken. We are told by teachers of Yogic lineages that one God will come to us in any form we choose if we are genuine in our faith. There can be a deep resonance with the concepts of Divine attributes associated with these figures of Hindu devotion but is that genuine faith? 

As a young woman, I was given a mantra for my meditation practice. Repeating sacred sounds, mantras is a technique used by many around the world. This mantra I received had a name of Hindu deity in it and the word namah. Namah represents the devotional part of the mantra, a salutation and a proclamation of surrender. My meditation developed and the mantra became an intimate companion in my life. After about 7 years of practice, I had a meltdown. I couldn't do it anymore. I felt so much inner conflict. I just wasn't feeling connected to this personification of Divine. I asked for help from a trusted swami, a monk in a yogic tradition. In gratitude, I was given an adjustment to my mantra that was more aligned with my beliefs. I could not adopt the Hindu God with authenticity.

Another aspect of devotion in the eastern world is dedication to a teacher. People love following gurus. This was first known to me by hearing of the Beatles and their exploration of the eastern ways. Why is Guru worship so popular? The Guru is in physical form, tangible and relatable. We are attracted to something we feel and see. Teachers inspire us and kindle our aspirations. There are holy men and women in many different traditions, a fact which seems to cross the boundaries of cultures. This type of loving devotion can get dangerous and derail our rationale and even have us vulnerable to manipulation. It has become known that many spiritual teachers, priests or gurus have exploited their communities financially or even sexually. When you mix devotion, love, and sex, you can get a pretty powerful cocktail that can have a lasting imprint on the victims of such abuse of power. I have learned that my primary yoga master Swami Satchidananda has done so as well. Multiple women came forward with reports of their sexual involvement with this supposedly celibate holy man. Now even though Swami Satchidananda’s disciples know, many continue to see him as no less than Divine. Many continue to worship him regardless of his hidden shadow life, regardless of the lies and betrayals. They worship him in recognition of the Light they saw in him and in gratitude for all the gifts they received. Is that ok? There is sweetness in the act of worship itself and any act of truly felt devotion has power. 

Opening the heart, loving, expressing affection is undeniably an important part of spiritual life. How can we express that authentically and in harmony with yogic teachings of the east? Let’s find what makes our hearts sing.

Picture
5 Comments
Dylan B.
12/15/2023 10:40:59 am

<3

Reply
Kathleen
12/15/2023 04:55:41 pm

You ask if it is ok to continue to worship Swami Satchidananda despite his lies and betrayals. Last month, two of his former secretaries filed a lawsuit in NYS, alleging that he sexually abused them. Although Satchidananda’s teachings brought light, peace and healing to many, sadly, he seems to have tainted his own legacy. You say “There is sweetness in the act of worship itself and any act of truly felt devotion has power.” Perhaps we err when we direct our devotion and worship towards a flawed man instead of towards God who accomplishes great things through imperfect instruments like Swami Satchidananda.

Reply
Helen Satya Bee
1/26/2025 03:01:34 am

Thank you Kathleen - I could not have put it better myself. I never knew Satchidananda - as you say he brought much light & yet he did not walk his talk like so many others…..
In the 80’s I had a similar experience with another ‘Guru’ who came on to me which was very shocking! I chose to ignore the bait, pretended it had not happened & walked away shaken by the experience thinking it was somehow my fault! Later he was rumbled & forced to leave the movement & I & several others left too. Someone said at the time ‘don’t throw the baby out with the bath water’ yet I did….
This time when I heard the news regarding Satchidananda I was not so surprised but shocked more by his refusal to own up & his devotees lying & covering up & ( some female Swamis also ) blaming & shaming the women!!!! This to me was & is far more shocking than another man who can’t keep it in his pants! This time however I chose not to throw the baby out & have continued to follow the teachings which are universal - I just do so from other literature & when I teach ( which I do remotely from the U.K. where I live I am based) have a Buddha head & flowers & crystals beside me. Sadly I feel less connected to IYI San Francisco as a result & wish they would take his photographs down - certainly off the altar as I refuse to bow down in front of someone who has broken several of the yamas & niyamas which means that I do not attend many classes myself as I get very triggered & angry seeing him sitting there which does not help my consciousness at all! Very sad. 🧘🏻‍♂️

Reply
Gustavo P Furtado
1/8/2024 07:39:56 am

Happy that you posted this text, Diane! Open and suggestive.

I have so many thoughts on all of this!

Gurus will rise and fall like the sun. Maya is maya. I hope to navigate past idealizations and vilifications (humans are so good at exaggeration!)

More and more I feel like my spirituality is just my own responsibility. I want to borrow respectfully and intelligently from other cultures and to be grateful for those who have shared valuable knowledge with me. But I also want to keep my own flame lit

Wishing you good things!! And hoping for more posts!

Reply
Gustavo P Furtado
1/8/2024 07:44:11 am

PS - Sorry I misspelled your name, Diana!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    December 2025
    August 2025
    April 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    May 2024
    March 2024
    December 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    March 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    August 2022
    April 2022
    January 2022
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Classes
  • Yoga Therapy
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact